Latest Posts:
flame11-24-2024 Three Word Post.....The Next Generation.... (Rep.#19,435) from: BigDogflameflame11-24-2024 The Totally Useless Thread IV (Rep.#165) from: BigDogflameflame11-24-2024 Brrrr (Rep.#14,944) from: BigDogflameflame11-23-2024 Gas price in your area (Rep.#7,276) from: stingrayflameflame11-23-2024 Not boat related (Rep.#42) from: stingrayflame
No members are browsing this topic
Forum Led by: BigDog, RiverLiver

 

[ Track this topic :: Email this topic :: Print this topic ]
add a reply to this topic create a new topic create a new poll
WATERDOGMale Offline
Gemini
HDF Silver Supporter
Don't Bother Me, I'm in Havi
10,000 post flame100 post flame100 post flame
MENIFEE, CA
Posts: 10,292
APPD 1.60
Post Rank: 8
ELIMINATOR EAGLE
Post Icon Posted: Jan. 29 2009,11:22 am Post # 1 see this member send this member a private message  quote this post in reply

Family of amoeba victim suing city
Attorney: Public notice should have been given

By David Bell
Wednesday, January 28, 2009 10:04 PM MST


The family of a boy who suffered a rare death caused by an amoeba in 2007 has filed suit against Lake Havasu City, Mohave County and the state of Arizona.

David K. Evans filed suit Sept. 4, 2008, in Mohave County Superior court over the Sept. 17, 2007, death of his 14-year-old son Aaron. The suit contends, “The defendants knew or should have known that Windsor Beach 4 was infected with Naegleria fowleri and of the fatal consequences of someone, such as Aaron K. Evans, coming in contact with Naegleria fowleri.”

Windsor Beach is located at the south end of Lake Havasu State Park, near the north entrance to the Bridgewater Channel.

David Diamond, an attorney with the law firm of Goldberg & Osborne representing David Evans and Aaron’s mother Amber Ricketts, said the issue is that notice should have been given to the public.

“Of course, the question really is what was the extent of the notice the folks (in the city, county and state) had to the presence of the amoeba and to what extent did they know it was a naturally occurring phenomena that could adversely affect people,” Diamond said. “It’s rare but not unheard of, there were other cases in Arizona and the U.S. So the question is, to what degree did the folks have knowledge of the amoeba and what steps did they take to protect the public. Should something have been done before this occurred?”

Lake Havasu City Attorney Paul Lenkowsky said the Phoenix law firm of Potts & Associates is handling the defense for the city.

“The city intends to vigorously contest the suit,” Lenkowsky said. “We don’t believe that the injury that occurred was a foreseeable risk on the part of the city, under the circumstances in which it occurred.”

Richard Weldon, who heads up Risk Management for Mohave County, was not available for comment.

Naegleria fowleri is a free-living amoeba found in water and soil worldwide. It’s most commonly found in warm areas of shallow water with little flow or current.

Only the species Naegleria fowleri can infect humans and even then it’s rare because infection occurs when the amoeba enters the nose, generally when a person is swimming underwater or diving. The infection cannot be spread person-to-person.

Health officials said symptoms could take one to 14 days to occur. Symptoms include headache, fever, nausea, vomiting and a stiff neck.

Death occurs generally in three to seven days.

Aaron Evans’ death was the sixth caused by Naegleria fowleri in 2007. Three occurred in the Orlando, Fla., area and two in Lubbock, Texas. A Buckeye boy was killed by the amoeba following a visit to Lake Pleasant in 2006. There was one death reported in 2008 — a 9-year-old boy that was swimming in Lake Elsinore, Calif.

The filing does not state a specific dollar amount sought in the suit, only “money damages sufficient to fully and fairly compensate plaintiff and statutory wrongful death beneficiaries for their losses,” legal costs and “such other and further relief” that the court deems as equitable.


"Damn you sure know how to fock things up."-GFR
Back to top
| Member # 2868 | Joined: 4-23-2007 |
ZiggyMale Offline
Cancer

Slum Lord
5,000 post flame1,000 post flame1,000 post flame100 post flame100 post flame100 post flame100 post flame
Oceanside, Ca./Lake Havasu, Az.
Posts: 7,441
APPD 0.96
Post Rank: 10
2016 Nordic 26 Deck
Post Icon Posted: Jan. 29 2009,11:41 am Post # 2 see this member send this member a private message  quote this post in reply

I sure hope this is about making them test the waters more regularly, posting warning signs and not about money......if I were to loose a loved one no amount of money could ever replace them, ever.
.
The scary thing for me is we were on that beach one week later with a broken boat so my daughter and her friend were swimming around there all day.


Ain't life Grand? Treat it that way.
The Love of my Life, Jan.
Back to top
| Member # 192 | Joined: 8-27-2003 |
WATERDOGMale Offline
Gemini
HDF Silver Supporter
Don't Bother Me, I'm in Havi
10,000 post flame100 post flame100 post flame
MENIFEE, CA
Posts: 10,292
APPD 1.60
Post Rank: 8
ELIMINATOR EAGLE
Post Icon Posted: Jan. 29 2009,12:11 pm Post # 3 see this member send this member a private message  quote this post in reply

Quote (Ziggy @ Jan. 29 2009,11:41 am)
I sure hope this is about making them test the waters more regularly, posting warning signs and not about money......if I were to loose a loved one no amount of money could ever replace them, ever.
.
The scary thing for me is we were on that beach one week later with a broken boat so my daughter and her friend were swimming around there all day.

I swim there all the time. The thing that make's me scared is that crap is only supposed to be in the brackish water that has no circulation. Havasu is going to look funny with a "Swim At Your Own Risk" sign posted every 50 feet on both sides.


"Damn you sure know how to fock things up."-GFR
Back to top
| Member # 2868 | Joined: 4-23-2007 |
GlassManMale Offline
Pisces
HDF Silver Supporter
Redondo Crew
5,000 post flame500 post flame100 post flame100 post flame
Redondo Beach, California, USA
Posts: 5,761
APPD 0.77
Post Rank: 13
Post Icon Posted: Jan. 29 2009,1:20 pm Post # 4 see this member send this member a private message  quote this post in reply

Found on the CDC site:

Is there a routine and rapid test for Naegleria in the water?

No. It can take weeks to grow and identify the ameba. Newer genetic detection tests for ameba are still under development. Water testing suggests that the amebae are so common that recreational water users should assume that there is a low level of risk when entering all warm fresh water in southern tier states.


How does the risk of Naegleria fowleri infection compare with other water-related risks?

Although the infections are severe, the risk of Naegleria fowleri infection is very low. There have been 33 reported infections in the U.S. during the 10 years from 1998 to 2007, despite millions of recreational water exposures each year. By comparison, during the ten years from 1996 to 2005, there were over 36,000 drowning deaths in the U.S.


Hard to think that anyone is at "Fault" here.


It's a fact of Life:

After Monday and Tuesday, even the Calendar says : WTF .......
Back to top
| Member # 617 | Joined: 4-29-2004 |
gigamurphMale Offline
Taurus
HDF Supporter
Boat Racer
1,000 post flame1,000 post flame100 post flame100 post flame100 post flame
Hemet, CA
Posts: 2,314
APPD 0.30
Post Rank: 28
Post Icon Posted: Jan. 29 2009,4:05 pm Post # 5 see this member send this member a private message  quote this post in reply

Quote (GlassMan @ Jan. 29 2009,1:20 pm)
Found on the CDC site:

Is there a routine and rapid test for Naegleria in the water?

No. It can take weeks to grow and identify the ameba. Newer genetic detection tests for ameba are still under development. Water testing suggests that the amebae are so common that recreational water users should assume that there is a low level of risk when entering all warm fresh water in southern tier states.


How does the risk of Naegleria fowleri infection compare with other water-related risks?

Although the infections are severe, the risk of Naegleria fowleri infection is very low. There have been 33 reported infections in the U.S. during the 10 years from 1998 to 2007, despite millions of recreational water exposures each year. By comparison, during the ten years from 1996 to 2005, there were over 36,000 drowning deaths in the U.S.


Hard to think that anyone is at "Fault" here.

Only one at fault would probably be "destiny". It's a damn shame that this tragedy happened but I don't believe LHC could have done anything to prevent it. It's a "natural" occurrance and it was unfortunate that this young man and just the right set of circumstances came together at just the right time. I'm with Ziggy; I hope this is more about more due diligence in testing and not money.

Holy$hit! If this thing turns against LHC and ends up costin' 'em; can you just imagine what it will bring down on the watersports world? "Swim At Your Own Risk" signs may just be the least of it!


"My lifestyle determines my deathstyle!" -Metallica
Back to top
| Member # 252 | Joined: 10-20-2003 |
CaliKatFemale Offline
Gemini

Kool Kat
1,000 post flame500 post flame100 post flame100 post flame100 post flame100 post flame
Cali Delta
Posts: 1,958
APPD 0.32
Post Rank: 33
Post Icon Posted: Jan. 29 2009,4:57 pm Post # 6 see this member send this member a private message  quote this post in reply

As sad as this is, it truly is a no fault situation.  We all have to assume there are risks involved with every activity we do.  Unless you're going to live life in a bubble (and that ain't living), you take your chances.

My mom has a friend who had a daughter about the same age as me.  The daughter was vacationing in Florida and contracted e coli from the ocean water.  By the time they figured it out, there was nothing they could do for her and she passed away.  She was in her early 30s.  As devastated as her family was, they accepted it.  Who were they going to sue?  Mother Nature?  Planet Earth?  All the pigs who pollute our oceans?  Athough the latter would be fine with me. :pissed

People need to accept some responsibility and ownership of the choices they make, and not point the finger at everyone else.

/soapbox


Edited by CaliKat on Jan. 29 2009,4:58 pm


"This is for all the friends I've known, this is for all the ones who've never left me alone. This is for all the ones I've lost along the way...thanks for being a part of today."
Back to top
| Member # 3232 | Joined: 1-01-2008 |
WATERDOGMale Offline
Gemini
HDF Silver Supporter
Don't Bother Me, I'm in Havi
10,000 post flame100 post flame100 post flame
MENIFEE, CA
Posts: 10,292
APPD 1.60
Post Rank: 8
ELIMINATOR EAGLE
Post Icon Posted: Jan. 30 2009,10:09 am Post # 7 see this member send this member a private message  quote this post in reply

As a side note. All of Windsor is State owned and nothing to do with LHC. Pretty sure that LHC will be dropped at the first hearing.


"Damn you sure know how to fock things up."-GFR
Back to top
| Member # 2868 | Joined: 4-23-2007 |
6 replies since Jan. 29 2009,11:22 am < Next Oldest | Next Newest >
 

[ Track this topic :: Email this topic :: Print this topic ]
add a reply to this topic create a new topic create a new poll

navbarlogo
The Colorado River WebRing
‹ Prev | Hub | Like | Join | Surprise | Next ›

Please help keep HDF free. If you enjoy this site, feel free to make a donation to keep it running. THANKS!